[Big Slim Sweet]

I hate these lists.

With that said

1) Pacquiao
2) Mayweather
3) Marquez
4) Donaire
5) Martinez
6) Hopkins
7) Bradley
8) Lopez
9) Ward
10) Froch

[Guest_Fitz_*]

Nice list Slim, I think we have the EXACT same list other than I have W.Klitschko and you have Lopez. It's like the exact same order and the change we do have is both our #8, haha.

[Guest_Fitz_*]

Oh wait, I have Mayweather at #1 and you have Pacquiao. But pretty close.

[SmartyBeardo]

1. SMartinez

2. Bradley

3. JMM

4. The Klit Siamese Twin Sisters

5. Donaire

6. Ward

7. Froch

8. BHop

9. PBF

10. Pac

Yes, I am serious.

[and the NEW]

That is an odd list Beardo, which Klit sister?

Maxy, can you please include Mayweather in your list where you would place him assuming he is not yet retired? Just to keep the criteria and therefore lists weighted accurately.

KidBazooka, you need to add numbers 6-10 to get your list included.

JLUVBABY, Gamboa will drop out of your list as you have two 4s, which will become 4 and 5 on your list in the spreadsheet. ALSO, can you please indicate whether you want Mayweather in the list (assuming he is being ranked and not retired for now and where you want to place him?). As said previously, need to do this to ensure the consistency of the rankings system.

On another note, not a lot of love for Pac over Mayweather. I agree with you below also Viper, that Pac and Mayweather need to work to be there, hence Pac has overtaken Mayweather on my list (despite the fact I think Mayweather would most likely beat him in a head to head).

This post has been edited by and the NEW: Feb 21 2011, 12:18 AM

[Guest_ViperSniper_*]

1. SMartinez

2. Bradley

3. JMM

4. The Klit Siamese Twin Sisters

5. Donaire

6. Ward

7. Froch

8. BHop

9. PBF

10. Pac

Yes, I am serious.

Wow. Could you try your best to break some of your list down? Good list, just curious to see your reasons for your rankings on number 1, 2, 4, 9 & 10? lol

As for the more popular choice of Mayweather/Pacquaio being number one, I think both maybe getting used to being regarded so high they forgot they had to actually had to work to get there, and gotta continue. They are both treading on very thin ice with Mayweather not testing himself like he should and most importantly being inactive could drop him off the lists all together.

As for Manny his approach to not only choosing his own opponents but has the nerves to choose a poor selection of opponents over legit fights is hurting not only his p4p status but also his career. Both fighters are slackin big time which they haven't really raised the bar that high in recent years it's understandable many fighters a creeping up, if not, already over taken them on several p4p lists! Big things have happened in boxing in the last 6 months or so where a lot of fighters are either coming out of their shells or rising to the occasion.

[True-Boxing-Fan]

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Sergio Martinez
3. Nonito Donaire
4. Floyd Mayweather
5. JM Marquez
6. Andre Ward
7. Tim Bradley
8. Carl Froch
9. JM Lopez
10. Vitali Klitschko

[JLUVBABY]

That is an odd list Beardo, which Klit sister?

Maxy, can you please include Mayweather in your list where you would place him assuming he is not yet retired? Just to keep the criteria and therefore lists weighted accurately.

KidBazooka, you need to add numbers 6-10 to get your list included.

JLUVBABY, Gamboa will drop out of your list as you have two 4s, which will become 4 and 5 on your list in the spreadsheet. ALSO, can you please indicate whether you want Mayweather in the list (assuming he is being ranked and not retired for now and where you want to place him?). As said previously, need to do this to ensure the consistency of the rankings system.

On another note, not a lot of love for Pac over Mayweather. I agree with you below also Viper, that Pac and Mayweather need to work to be there, hence Pac has overtaken Mayweather on my list (despite the fact I think Mayweather would most likely beat him in a head to head).

if we are including mayweather then i for sure rank him number 1 without a question... with donaire at number 2... and so on and so fourth...

[Maxy]

OK, I've completely changed my list for the sake of and the New thread. Whatever Mayweather told Hype ain't of any relevance though and I don't see Floyd fighting again before May which means he shouldn't be in any list but I'll bow down and put him in. He's dropped to 4 though due to inactivity. I'd like to put Gamboa in there but until he gets the big fight I can't justify it yet.


1. Pacquiao
2. Martinez
3. Donaire
4. Mayweather
5. Lopez
6. Marquez
7. Froch
8. Ward
9. Wonjongkam
10. Hopkins

[Run and Gun Game...]

1) Pacquiao
2) W. Klitchko
3) Mayweather
4) Marquez
5) Donaire
6) Martinez
7) Bradley
8) Lopez
9) Ward
10) Froch