Replies

[D-MARV]

Bernard Hopkins - 56(32)-5-1

Highlights:
One of the greatest middleweights of all time
- 20 defenses of the Middleweight crown
- Oldest Middleweight champion of all time
- Title holder in two weight classes


Notable wins: Felix Trinidad, Kelly Pavlik, Winky Wright, Antonio Tarver, Oscar De Hoya


Floyd Mayweather Jr - 39(25)-0

Highlights:
-6 time champ in 5 different weight classes
-Bronze medalist in 1996 olympic games


Notable wins: Diego Corrales, Jose Luis Castillo (2x), Zab Judah, Ricky Hatton, Oscar De La Hoya

[buford54]

For now it's Hops. Considering the calibre of opposition available to him, he has fought everyone in and around his weight class.
Floyd has a huge pool of good fighters surrounding him and has, thus far, chosen to work his way into BIG money.

As far as the losses Hopkins has sustained versus Floyd's being undefeated:
All of Hopkins recent losses (JT, Calzaghe) can be strongly disputed and are still argued to this day.
Floyd has at least 2 fights where his wins can be disputed (JLC 1 and ODLH).

While Floyd has moved from 130 to 154 through the course of his career, remember he started much younger than Hops and had grew into the weights in 5-7 pound increments.
Hops, at 40, was still making 160. He then jumped 15 pounds in one shot and dominated the champ there.