Replies

[and the NEW]

Guys (and girls if there are any here).

I'm going to create a fighthype consensus pound for pound list.

Just put down your top 10 in order from 1 to 10.

You must enter exactly 10 for me to feed it into the spreadsheet, with the number 1 being given 10 points, down to the 10th guy getting 1 point, per list they make.

I will feed all the lists into a spreadsheet and tally the points to see what the fighthype average (consensus) P4P list is. Should be interesting.

I'll have to give a little more thought to my exact list, so will post it once I create it.

Cheers

[and the NEW]

FIGHTHYPE, official consensus P4P list is:

Mayweather
Pacquaio
Martinez
Marquez
Donaire
Ward
Hopkins
Bradley
Lopez
Froch
W Klit
V Klit
John
Wonjongkam
Bute
Gamboa
Montiel
Segura
Cotto
Khan

What was notable, both Mayweather and Pac were well and truly the top 2.

The next 3 guys were extremelly close on points, that being Martinez, Marquez and Donaire.

There was then a BIG gap to Ward, BHOP and Bradley who were all very close on points also.

Then there was another big gap down to everyone else.

Surprises for me: I didn't expect Martinez to get all the way up to #3. I also didn't think Lopez or Froch would get infront of the likes of both the Klits and Chris John who IMO opinion have much larger and longer bodies of work and are still at the top of their respective divisions.

This post has been edited by and the NEW: Feb 28 2011, 02:36 AM

[maac]

The positions between 1 and 2 are very close. May have 11 votes
for first and Pac 10, but overall Pac have more points, considering
a system rating granting 10 points for first place, 9 for second,
etc. until and 1 for the tenth position.
# people voting so far: 23

FIGHTHYPE, official consensus P4P list is:

Mayweather
Pacquaio
Martinez
Marquez
Donaire
Ward
Hopkins
Bradley
Lopez
Froch
W Klit
V Klit
John
Wonjongkam
Bute
Gamboa
Montiel
Segura
Cotto
Khan

What was notable, both Mayweather and Pac were well and truly the top 2.

The next 3 guys were extremelly close on points, that being Martinez, Marquez and Donaire.

There was then a BIG gap to Ward, BHOP and Bradley who were all very close on points also.

Then there was another big gap down to everyone else.

Surprises for me: I didn't expect Martinez to get all the way up to #3. I also didn't think Lopez or Froch would get infront of the likes of both the Klits and Chris John who IMO opinion have much larger and longer bodies of work and are still at the top of their respective divisions.

[and the NEW]

The positions between 1 and 2 are very close. May have 11 votes
for first and Pac 10, but overall Pac have more points, considering
a system rating granting 10 points for first place, 9 for second,
etc. until and 1 for the tenth position.
# people voting so far: 23

No worries Beardo.

Maac, are you saying Pac had more votes than Mayweather? I added all the points, you can do so if you want, but Mayweather definately finished above Pac.

[maac]

No worries Beardo.

Maac, are you saying Pac had more votes than Mayweather? I added all the points, you can do so if you want, but Mayweather definately finished above Pac.

No, in fact as i mentioned, May have 11 mentions for top 1,
for 10 of Pac (minimum difference), but excluding votes for
positions 1 and 2, Pac wins. All ok.

BUT now my list:

1. Pac
2. Mayweather
3. Martinez
4. Donaire
5. JMM
6. Hopkins
7. Ward
8. Campbell
9. Bute
10.Khan

So, now Pac = Mayweather in top 1, i think, isn't?


This post has been edited by maac: Mar 1 2011, 09:56 AM