Floyd fought a nasty bout with Castillo and gutted it out...it didn't look all that great, but he pulled it off, period. He was taking punches, and throwing just as many. Its never a good idea to go by the judges scores cards...especially Shrek Lederman's...unless you've had too much to drink during the fight and simply uses his cards to somewhat keep up
They aren't messed up all the time, but I wouldn't consider them the gospel either.
He damn near had the recent Donaire fight a shit out, PLEASE! Thats the point of watching a fight carefully and looking for what actually lands, so that you can judge for yourself. Having a DVR would definitely help for times like this. Hell, it helped me to hear Joe Cortez tell Floyd and Victor to resume fighting at the end of the 4th...though several people here and on Facebook, were yelling that they didn't hear him say it.
As far as I know, when a ref has both guys settled in neutral corners and signals them to meet in the center of the ring...its time to fight!...but unqualified observers wouldn't know that. I've watched several Floyd fights with people and they swear that he is getting his ass kicked, but they dont understand the shoulder roll, how he catched punches on his elbows, and how ALL fighters slip punches...though it looks like they are getting hit. Its about knowing what to look for when a fight is in progress.
Oh yeah...Mayweather by decision. He would move to much and Maidana wouldn't have a decent chance to plant his feet and throw hard effective punches. Besides, its obvious to see when Maidana is resetting to get in position to adjust, so that straight right by FMJ would spell trouble for him. I like Maidana as a fighter and I'll give him a chance against anybody, but this isn't a good fight for him.